Two jewellers can quote the same old bangles at the same gold rate and still leave you with final bills that differ by ₹25,000. The gap rarely sits in the headline rate. It sits in what happens around it: the deduction on your old piece, the wastage and making charges on the new one, and how the shop tests purity before it names a number.
This guide is for buyers who want to exchange old gold jewellery for new and are not sure what a fair deal looks like. It explains how an old gold jewellery exchange is priced, which deduction percentages are actually published, what Tanishq, Lalitha, Khazana and CaratLane state in their terms, and what to expect from an independent local shop. If you are still deciding what to buy with the credit, our buyer's guide to gold jewellery covers budget and making charges in more depth.
Exchange, buyback and old jewellery exchange: three terms that get mixed up
Shops use these words loosely, and the difference changes what you walk away with.
Exchange means the shop values your old gold and adjusts that value against a new purchase from the same shop. Tanishq and CaratLane both state that exchange gives credit, not cash.
Buyback means a shop repurchases jewellery it sold you, usually against the original invoice. Kisna's published buyback policy, for example, returns 97% of the gold value at current pricing, and it asks for the original product, invoice, and certificate.
Deduction is the percentage the shop subtracts from the tested gold value to cover melting, refining, and handling loss.
Wastage (also called VA, or value addition) is a charge on the new piece for gold lost while manufacturing it. It has nothing to do with your old gold, but it is where many shops recover a "zero deduction" promise.
HUID (Hallmark Unique Identification) is the six-character alphanumeric code on BIS-hallmarked jewellery. It lets the shop and you confirm purity on the BIS Care app instead of arguing over a test reading.
XRF (X-ray fluorescence) is the test method behind machines such as Tanishq's Karatmeter. It reads the metal composition without damaging the piece.
The relationship to keep in mind is simple. An old jewellery exchange runs on two ledgers. The first is your credit: tested purity, net weight, same-day rate, minus the deduction. The second is the price of the new piece: gold value, wastage, making charges, and GST. A fair deal means both ledgers are acceptable. Most buyers inspect only the first.
How the exchange value is calculated
The core arithmetic is the same everywhere: net gold weight, multiplied by the purity fraction, multiplied by the shop's same-day rate, minus the deduction. Purity fractions are 0.999 for 24K, 0.916 for 22K, and 0.750 for 18K.
Diagram showing exchange credit equals net weight times purity times same-day rate minus deduction
Three details decide whether the number is honest.
Net weight is not the weight on the scale. Stones, beads, enamel, lac filling, and mixed metals are rarely valued as gold. Industry guidance quoted by Business Standard says the standard practice is to value only the gold weight and ignore stones, or pay a nominal amount for them. If your old necklace has a heavy lac-filled pendant, the scale weight and the gold weight are two different figures.
The making charge you paid before is gone. Whatever you paid in labour on the old piece is not credited back. If the old piece was bought from Tanishq, the company's terms say making charges, taxes and any discount on the original invoice are deducted in full when you exchange it.
The credit rate and the selling rate may differ. Tanishq's exchange page states that its buying rate equals its selling rate. Not every shop does that. A Nagpur jeweller's published guide describes some shops running a gap of ₹100 to ₹250 per gram between the rate they sell at and the rate they credit old gold at.
On a 40 g set, that gap alone is ₹4,000 to ₹10,000 before any deduction. When you ask about the gold jewellery exchange rate, ask two questions: what is today's selling rate for 22K, and is the credit rate the same?
Worked example: why a deduction is not the whole story
Take 40 g of old bangles tested at 22K, exchanged against a new 50 g 22K necklace. Use an illustrative rate of ₹12,500 per gram (check the live figure on our gold rates page before you plan anything).
Pure-gold equivalent: 40 × 0.916 = 36.64 g. At ₹12,500 that is ₹4,58,000 of gold value.
Shop A offers a 0% deduction and charges 18% making on the new piece. New piece: ₹6,25,000 of gold plus ₹1,12,500 making, ₹7,37,500, plus 3% GST, ₹7,59,625. Credit ₹4,58,000. You pay ₹3,01,625.
Shop B deducts 3% and charges 12% making. Credit: ₹4,44,260. New piece: ₹6,25,000 plus ₹75,000 making, ₹7,00,000, plus 3% GST, ₹7,21,000. You pay ₹2,76,740.
Comparison of two shops showing the shop with a 3 percent deduction costing 24,885 rupees less overall
Shop B costs ₹24,885 less even though it takes a deduction. The numbers are illustrative, but the pattern is the point: Business Standard's reporting on exchange schemes quotes advisers warning that some retailers show a higher headline exchange rate and recover it through elevated making charges on the new purchase. Always compare the total payable for the same design, not the credit line.
Deduction percentages: what is actually published
There is no regulated deduction for old gold in India. Each shop sets its own, which is why the numbers below come from different kinds of sources. Treat them as data points, not a rule book.
CaratLane publishes a 4% standard deduction on old gold value when you exchange into 22KT jewellery. Exchange into diamond-studded jewellery set in up to 18KT gold is described without that deduction.
Tanishq's general programme terms say deductions apply and point you to the store for details. Its October 2026 festive communications described a flat 0% deduction on old gold of 18KT and above across India, and a flat extra 1KT of value for customers in Tamil Nadu. Offers like this carry end dates, so confirm the current terms at the counter.
Slab structures exist among newer brands. True Diamond, for example, publishes 1% for 24Kt, 2.5% for 22Kt, 5% for 18Kt and 7.5% for 14Kt, with purity tested at an external lab and reported in writing. Lower karat means a larger cut because refining recovers less.
Independent jewellers publish everything from a stated 0% deduction (a Nagpur jeweller's page promises it for 22K and 24K gold from any source) to the claim, from another Nagpur jeweller's resale guide, that most jewellers deduct 10 to 20 percent of tested weight as wastage or refining loss.
Refining and melting alone are described by IIFL's explainer as typically 1 to 3%, with extra wastage deducted on non-hallmarked pieces where purity is uncertain.
A working benchmark that follows from those sources: for HUID-hallmarked 22K plain gold, a quote in the 0 to 4% range is consistent with what organised retailers publish. A cut well above that on hallmarked gold needs an explanation, and for non-hallmarked old pieces you should expect a higher cut because the shop is carrying the purity risk. Our explainer on hallmark gold versus KDM gold shows why a KDM-era piece is harder to value and why shops treat it differently.
Purity testing at exchange: what happens at the counter
The purity result sets the credit, so this step deserves more attention than the rate.
XRF testing. Tanishq describes its Karatmeter as testing three points on each jewel. Press coverage describes a glass-walled melting and valuation area so you can watch. XRF reads the surface layer of the metal, so it is fast and non-destructive, but it can be thrown by solder joints, hollow construction, and plating. Asking for a reading from more than one point is reasonable.
Touchstone and acid. Many smaller shops still use a touchstone with acid reagents. It works well in experienced hands and poorly in rushed ones. A scratch on an inconspicuous part is normal; one on a visible face is not.
Melting and fire assay. Some shops melt the piece and test the resulting mass. Fire assay at an external lab is the most reliable and the slowest. True Diamond's published policy relies on exactly this kind of external report.
What changes the outcome:
A HUID-hallmarked piece carries certified purity, so the reading is accepted faster, and the wastage cut some jewellers apply to non-hallmarked pieces generally does not arise. The metal value does not change. What the hallmark protects is the deduction side. Our guide to checking a gold hallmark walks through verifying HUID before you leave home, and the post on hallmark purity numbers explains why 916, 750 and 585 behave differently at the counter.
Hollow bangles, lac-filled jhumkas and anything with soldered chain links make the scale weight misleading. Ask the jeweller to state the net gold weight and the tested karat separately.
Gold-plated and imitation items are not accepted for exchange at organised chains (one third-party explainer says so for Tanishq), so do not bring them expecting partial credit.
Ask for the tested karat and net weight in writing before you choose a new design. If a shop refuses to put its own test result on paper, treat the quote as unfinished.
Wastage and making charges: where the real money moves
Wastage has two meanings in a gold exchange conversation, and shops sometimes blur them.
On the old piece, "wastage" means the deduction for melting and refining loss. On the new piece, wastage (or VA) is a manufacturing charge priced as a percentage of gold weight. These are separate lines on separate ledgers. A shop that advertises "no deduction" has not removed the second one.
Lalitha Jewellery makes this visible in its pre-booking scheme, which advertises no wastage charges on jewellery bought through it and lets you pay upfront or exchange old jewellery against the booking.
An analysis in Asianet's money coverage notes that making charges on new jewellery can run 15 to 25 percent, and that the labour you paid on the old piece is lost. Those two facts together explain why a hand-made temple set and a machine-made chain should not be compared on the credit line alone.
A reliable habit: before you exchange, ask for the new piece's price broken into gold value, wastage or making, and GST. Then run the exchange through the same invoice and compare the final line.
Brand exchange policies compared
The table below uses terms published by each brand or, where noted, secondary summaries. Policies change, and offers expire, so treat the table as a checklist of questions, not a promise. The last column describes what independent local shops commonly publish or quote.
Tanishq | Lalitha | Khazana | CaratLane | Independent local shop | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Accepts | Plain 24K, 22K, 18K gold and coins; programme pages also cite 9KT to 22KT | Own-purchase jewellery; other jewellers' gold tested for purity | 24K, 22K, 18K from Khazana or any jeweller | Plain gold above 14Kt, coins, biscuits, bars | Usually 22K and 24K; lower karat at a higher cut |
Published deduction | Store-specific; 0% on 18KT+ in recent festive offer | 100% value on own pieces with receipt; other gold by purity | No percentage found in public material | 4% for 22KT exchange; none stated for diamond jewellery up to 18KT | 0% claimed by some, 1 to 7.5% on slab policies, higher where purity is uncertain |
Purity testing | Karatmeter (XRF), 3 points per piece | Not detailed publicly | Certified appraisers, in your presence | Not detailed in terms; PAN and purity declaration required | Touchstone, XRF or melting; quality varies by shop |
Bill needed? | Tanishq's current page says no bill required; older terms ask for an invoice | Original receipt for 100% value | Not stated | Declaration; invoice not the stated test | Often required for 0% claims |
Studded pieces | Not accepted under general programme; own studded pieces examined | Not detailed | Not detailed | Plain gold only in; diamond jewellery out | Stones usually ignored or paid a nominal value |
Cash option | Credit against new purchase | Credit | Credit against new purchase | No cash, no coins | Often cash buying is a separate rate |
Tanishq jewellery exchange policy
Tanishq runs two tracks. The general exchange programme accepts plain gold and coins bought anywhere. The Tanishq Exchange Programme covers jewellery sold by Tanishq, Mia by Tanishq or Zoya. Under the general programme, studded products are not accepted, deductions are store-specific, and the store's valuation is final.
On the Tanishq diamond jewellery exchange policy, the useful distinction is direction. Old plain gold can be exchanged for diamond jewellery, which suits buyers upgrading from heavy gold.
Studded jewellery you bought from Tanishq returns through the Tanishq Exchange Programme and is examined for purity, defects, stone condition, and originality. The terms also state that products outside the listed categories must be checked at the store.
For Tanishq jewellery exchange offers, the 0% deduction on 18KT and above and the extra 1KT in Tamil Nadu were the October 2026 festive headlines. Offers change, so ask whether the offer applies to your karat and whether it is combined with a making-charge discount or replaces one.
Lalitha jewellery exchange offer
Lalitha Jewellery (spelt Lalithaa in its own materials) is a Chennai-based chain. A gold exchange offer in Lalitha Jewellery mainly shows up in two places: the pre-booking scheme and the standard policy for its own pieces.
For the Lalitha Jewellery old gold exchange rate, one scheme summary states that its own old jewellery is valued at the day's gold rate with 100% exchange value, provided you produce the original purchase receipt.
That is a secondary summary rather than a retrieved Lalithaa terms page, so confirm the wording on your bill before you rely on it. For gold bought elsewhere, third-party profiles say it is tested and deducted according to purity against the 22K standard. Ask the counter for the percentage in numbers.
When you compare a Lalitha jewellery old gold exchange offer with Tanishq's in Tamil Nadu, line up three items: the credit rate, the deduction, and the VA on the new piece.
Khazana jewellery old gold exchange
Khazana's public guide says it accepts 24K, 22K, and 18K gold from Khazana or any other jeweller, appraises it with standard testing methods, and carries out each step in your presence.
The final value is calculated at the prevailing showroom rate and adjusted against the new purchase. In the material I reviewed, Khazana does not publish a deduction percentage, so the questions to ask are the ones above: the percentage in writing, the credit rate and the VA.
CaratLane jewellery exchange
CaratLane's jewellery exchange programme has more published detail than most chains. Old gold must be plain, above 14Kt. It can be exchanged for diamond jewellery in up to 18KT gold, while exchanging into 22KT jewellery incurs the 4% standard deduction.
You cannot take cash or gold coins in return. Exchange purchases are excluded from the 15-day money-back guarantee, and the lifetime exchange policy applies instead. The brand's own explainer also lists PAN and a signed purity-and-weight declaration as documents.
Jewellery companies listed on the stock exchange, and why it matters here
Buyers often search for jewellery companies listed on the stock exchange when they want reassurance before handing over gold. The relationship worth knowing: Tanishq and CaratLane both belong to Titan Company, which is listed.
Kalyan Jewellers, Senco Gold, PC Jeweller and Thangamayil are other listed names. As far as public information shows, Lalithaa and Khazana are family-run chains that are not listed.
Listing means annual reports, disclosure rules, and auditors outside the shop. It does not change an exchange quote. A listed company can offer a 4% deduction and an unlisted one can offer 0%, or the reverse. Use listing as a signal for accountability, and use the written exchange breakdown as the signal for price.
Exchange gold coin for jewellery: what changes
If you want to exchange gold coins for jewellery, the process differs in three ways from jewellery-for-jewellery.
First, purity is simpler. A 24K coin carries 0.999 fineness, so the test is a confirmation and not a negotiation. Tanishq's general programme accepts coins bought from other sellers, and CaratLane accepts coins, biscuits and bars as old gold input.
Second, you lose the coin's premium. The small making charge or retail premium you paid when buying the coin is not credited back. MMTC-PAMP's own guidance on exchange notes states that making charges paid on old jewellery are not treated as gold value, and the same logic applies to coin premiums.
Third, keep the sealed packaging and assay card. A coin in an intact certified blister is quick to verify. A loose coin gets tested and may be treated like scrap.
Jewellery shops with exchange offers: finding them near you
Every exchange offer on gold jewellery at a local shop tends to follow a festival calendar: Dhanteras, Akshaya Tritiya, wedding-season windows. These offers tend to change one of three things: the deduction, the making charge, or a free coin on a minimum purchase. Our Dhanteras 2026 guide shows how those three levers appear in named jeweller offers, and the News section tracks festive offer roundups as they go live.
To find jewellery shops with exchange offers in your city, start from the city pages for Ahmedabad, Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Pune, Jaipur or Kolkata, or use the verified jewellers filter and the gold jewellery category to shortlist shops. Then use the Inquire button to ask three questions in writing before you visit: the current deduction in percent, whether the credit rate equals the selling rate, and the making charge on the design you want. Replies in writing help if you later need to compare or dispute a quote.
How to run a fair exchange, step by step
Checklist graphic with six checks to complete before exchanging old gold
Get the rate first. Note the shop's same-day 22K selling rate and ask whether the credit rate is identical.
Ask for the deduction in percent and grams. A shop that says "minimal" has not answered.
Watch the test. Stay while each piece is tested, and ask for a reading from more than one point on chains and hollow pieces.
Get the net weight and karat in writing. Stones, lac and enamel should be excluded and listed.
Price the new piece separately. Ask for gold value, wastage or making, and GST as three lines for the same design at two shops.
Take an itemised bill. The invoice should show the old gold credit as its own line and the HUID of the new piece. A new piece with no HUID is a reason to stop, and our post on fake hallmark gold explains the risk.
Walk away if the credit rate is lower than the selling rate with no explanation, if a shop melts your piece out of sight, or if it refuses to write the tested karat down.



















